A group of former officials and judges offered their greetings to another group of former officials who expressed concern about the “politics of hate” in an open letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, accusing Allegedly, this group is trying to sway public opinion and indulge in “signaling virtue”.
Calling themselves ‘Citizens with Concern’, the group said it did not believe the open letter to Modi by the Constitutional Conduct Group (CCG) – the name of the association of former officials – had “sincere motives”. “.
They said the letter was the group’s way of expressing its frustration at public opinion that was still “behind Modi” and cited the BJP’s recent election victory.
Eight former judges, 97 former officials and 92 former armed forces officers signed an open letter written to Modi in response to a letter criticizing him and other CCG BJP governments, signed by 108 former officials office.
“Their anger and anguish are not just empty virtue signals, they are actually fueling the politics of hate they seek to counter by trying to create hatred against the government.” current by patent biases and their misleading descriptions,” “Concerned Citizens” says.
“The fact that these open letters echo the same language, have the same tenor and use ideologically biased terms clearly speaks for itself.” The group attempted to draw attention in the direction of “the striking similarity between the phraseology of the CCG missions and the statements made in the Western media or by Western agencies” which cast doubt on the intentions of the CCG. the group.
It also called for the alleged “silence” of the violence following the opinion poll in West Bengal.
“It shows their cynical and undisciplined approach to issues,” the Modi defense group said.
“Similar attitudes shape their response (or rather, no reaction at all) to the numerous incidents of violence in different states ruled by different political parties and the targets of violations. human rights negatively affect the livelihoods of the poor regardless of their religion,” it said.
Former judges and officials allege that the CCG’s “researched shortcomings” exposed it.
They also stated that cases of major community violence had decreased “significantly” under the BJP government, which was appreciated by the public.
“This has provoked groups like the CCG to highlight sporadic instances of community violence that no society can completely eradicate,” it said.
108 former civil servants have written to Modi, urging him to call for an end to what they call “hate politics” allegedly carried out “supportively” by governments under the BJP’s control.
In an open letter, they said, “we are witnessing a frenzied ravage of hatred in a country where the sacrificial altar is not limited to Muslims and members of minority communities. others but the Constitution itself”.
In the letter of protest, the group ‘Citizens with Concern’ advised former civil servants not to “make up a false story about the use of state power”.
It alleges that the other group’s real aim was to promote a counter-narrative against “pre-planned attacks on peaceful processions during Hindu festivals, possibly in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat or New Delhi”.
It accused the group of having “double standards”, creating a problem from “not a problem”, and having a “distorted mindset”.
The group alleges that the CCG’s attempt to “use its rich vocabulary to attract international attention, promote moves against democratically elected governments” is a “disagreement.” stability of our society”.
It also alleges that recent controversies regarding the hijab and halal certification among others are the operation of “given interests” that want to perpetuate the narrative of “Islamic persecution” and “repression of Islam”. Hindu dictatorship and Hindu nationalism” according to the BJP.
“Such a story receives recognition and encouragement from international lobbies that want to stifle India’s progress,” it stated.
“The so-called intellectuals, a group of retired civil servants, and their backed international lobbies seek to exploit this narrative to create political and social rifts in India and weaken the country from within on the pretext that they are serving some higher constitutional goal. when they are serving their own ego,” it said.
The group advised CCG to free itself from “personal biases and suggest possible solutions”, and asked CCG not to “sow fear and falsehood, seek to fan fire of separatism based on religion and even Polishization”.