It isn’t the primary sign that Russia is ready to carry Europe hostage to pure gasoline costs, that are escalating dramatically. However with Europe presently dealing with an power crunch, the context and timing are important — on either side of the Atlantic. It is fairly clear that each Washington and Brussels must thoughts what’s on the thoughts of Chizhov — and particularly Putin.
For Europe, the worth of not cozying as much as Russia may very well be debilitating gasoline shortages this winter, to not point out exploding gasoline costs. Since pure gasoline is the first heating gasoline for Europe, it is a doubtlessly existential menace. And currently, costs have proven an inclination to swing broadly, typically on the whim of, or prompted by, off-hand remarks uttered by one man: Vladimir Putin.
This type of hardly refined stress comes at a most delicate second for Europe.
Europe may very well be at an inflection level in its energy-driven vulnerability to Russia, for 2 causes.
A brand new pipeline from Russia’s gasoline fields to Germany — dubbed Nord Stream 2 — is transferring forward. It figures to shore up Europe’s entry to gasoline, but additionally to grant Russia much more management over that entry, one thing the US has identified because it opposed the undertaking. (Not too long ago, the Biden administration waived sanctions associated to it, giving an efficient inexperienced mild, regardless of its considerations.)
On the similar time, Europe is forging forward with a transition away from fossil fuels and towards clear, renewable power sources. However that transition hasn’t occurred but. As Europe appears for a bridge from dirtier sources like oil and coal, comparatively clear pure gasoline is seen as match.
And for gasoline, Europe depends on imports — notably from Russia.
As Germany and France search to cut back their reliance on nuclear power, they will probably flip to pure gasoline, no less than till extra wind and photo voltaic tasks might be introduced on-line.
Putin, one may guess, might be viewing this as a uncommon alternative to train essential politico-economic leverage. With Nord Stream 2 nonetheless within the works, Russia is already Europe’s fundamental gasoline provider, accounting for 41% of its imports. A flip to gasoline by Europe, and a brand new pipeline to Russia to get it, solely stands to spice up Putin’s energy.
Putin has already been quietly demonstrating simply what life may very well be like for a continent that has turn into deeply, maybe existentially, reliant on the Kremlin to produce its most important power wants. Russia is transferring solely restricted portions via the present pipeline system that transits Ukraine, and its state gasoline producer, Gazprom, is filling home shares earlier than replenishing storage websites in Europe.
With power costs rising and the worldwide financial system struggling to maneuver ahead after its post-2020 rebound, brief gasoline provides are already placing elements of Europe liable to energy-driven stagflation. These pressures might very effectively intensify, offering a doable foretaste of what may very well be on the near-term horizon, till Europe manages a reputable and sustainable transition to renewable power.
Putin would clearly see a accomplished EU transition away from gasoline, and towards renewables, as a looming menace to his affect. It is but another excuse for Putin to look to Nord Stream 2 to reap as a lot revenue (monetary and geopolitical) as doable earlier than the EU can pull off its inexperienced conversion.
The US could not just like the pipeline — former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo referred to as it a instrument of Russian “coercion” — however Washington in all probability cannot do a lot about it. Having already irritated so many forces in Western Europe over a number of points, together with the US and NATO withdrawal from Afghanistan and the secretively crafted US-UK-Australia safety partnership, the Biden administration should tread very rigorously certainly.
The US could have non-geopolitical causes for opposing Nord Stream 2 — and it might need cause to see American-supplied pure gasoline as a doable reply for Europe. America stays the most important single provider to Europe of liquefied pure gasoline, which might be shipped through tankers.
Nonetheless, LNG is dearer, depends on long-distance provide, and have to be transformed from liquid to gasoline on arrival. And there is already heavy competitors from different areas, particularly China, for LNG. Nord Stream 2 would lead to a assured provide of pure gasoline to Europe, presuming EU member states approve it within the subsequent a number of months. So for Europe, it stays an interesting possibility.
Russia’s warnings to Europe may be seen as a warning to the US to again off its decided opposition to Nord Stream 2 — and its opposition to Russia’s broader efforts to kind extra binding ties to western Europe. Nord Stream is successfully a fait accompli. Nonetheless, the perceived American hostility to it might drive yet one more wedge between Europe and America, at time when the Trump and now Biden administrations have completed sufficient to degrade transatlantic ties.
In that sense, the US ought to again off and let the pipeline proceed with out a lot grievance. Till Europe breaks its reliance on fossil fuels and results a inexperienced transition in full, Putin will hold an higher hand.